ScorecardBrokers & Exchanges (who's right about brokers & exchanges) › ICE

ICE analyst scorecard · Intercontinental Exchange

30 rating changes on ICE in the last 12 months. 54% of bullish calls were right at 30 days. Street grade C on 28 scored calls. Consensus target $187, 19% above the last close.

Graded through 2026-09-14 · last close $157.27 (2026-09-14). Rebuilt every morning.

Street grade
C 53.6%
Rating changes, 12 mo
30
Bullish calls right at 30d
53.6% of 28
Bearish calls right at 30d
Consensus target
$187 +19.1%
Firms covering
14
Price targets hit (90d)
19.0% of 21

Holds on ICE, read: 0 cut to or raised to Hold (graded as the change) · 5 Holds whose target leaned 10%+ one way (graded that way, 20.0% right) · 2 true Holds, not graded.

Firm by firm

FirmCallsScoredRightAccuracyGradeAvg 30dAvg 90dLatestDateTarget
UBS 444 100.0% A +6.7% +11.2% Buy2026-07-31 $195
TD Cowen 443 75.0% A +2.3% +6.7% Buy2026-07-31 $177
Barclays 884 50.0% C +0.9% +0.3% Overweight2026-07-31 $182
Morgan Stanley 751 20.0% F -1.8% -3.0% Equal-Weight2026-07-10 $163
Goldman Sachs 111 +26.9% Buy2026-06-30 $180
JPMorgan 221 +1.4% +8.5% Overweight2025-10-31 $180
Piper Sandler 331 -2.6% -11.5% Overweight2026-07-15 $190
Raymond James 110 -3.0% +4.7% Strong Buy2025-10-13 $210

Dimmed rows have fewer than 4 scored calls on ICE — too few to grade.

Every call, last 12 months

DateFirmChangeActionGraded asPrice at callRun before+30d+60d+90dTarget · 90d checkHit
2026-07-31 UBS Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $152.48 +20.3% +5.4% $195
2026-07-31 TD Cowen Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $152.48 +20.3% +5.4% $177
2026-07-31 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $152.48 +20.3% +5.4% $182
2026-07-15 Piper Sandler Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $139.84 -0.2% +10.7% +12.5% $190
2026-07-10 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained Leans bullish · Equal-Weight, target +20% $135.26 -3.6% +11.3% +16.6% $163
2026-07-09 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $135.11 -4.6% +11.4% +16.8% $180
2026-07-07 UBS Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $136.45 -3.6% +9.8% +15.6% $190
2026-06-30 Goldman Sachs Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $123.11 -16.7% +26.9% +30.5% $180
2026-06-22 TD Cowen Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $131.34 -14.1% +8.5% +22.8% $153
2026-05-01 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $154.75 -2.1% -6.3% -20.4% +1.0% $201 missed
2026-04-15 Piper Sandler Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $165.07 +2.2% -6.5% -15.1% -16.6% $211 missed
2026-04-10 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained Leans bullish · Equal-Weight, target +16% $160.60 +2.3% -1.7% -11.9% -15.9% $187 missed
2026-04-08 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $167.79 +1.2% -7.1% -17.1% -18.7% $198 missed
2026-02-10 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained Leans bullish · Equal-Weight, target +11% $164.81 -0.7% -3.8% -0.3% -4.2% $183 missed
2026-02-06 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $169.00 +4.4% -1.9% -1.6% -7.6% $193 missed
2026-01-15 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained True hold · target +3% $173.28 +8.3% -11.4% -6.8% -4.7% $180 missed not graded
2026-01-14 TD Cowen Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $172.94 +7.2% -11.9% -6.6% -6.3% $193 missed
2026-01-14 Piper Sandler Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $172.94 +7.2% -11.9% -6.6% -6.3% $195 missed
2026-01-08 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $161.98 +2.5% +4.6% +2.4% +3.6% $182 missed
2026-01-07 UBS Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $161.92 +3.1% +4.4% +2.4% +2.7% $195 missed
2025-12-22 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained True hold · target +7% $161.45 +4.5% +6.5% -4.6% -2.6% $174 missed not graded
2025-10-31 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $146.29 -10.1% +7.3% +11.5% +19.7% $183 hit
2025-10-31 JPMorgan Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $146.29 -10.1% +7.3% +11.5% +19.7% $180 hit
2025-10-31 TD Cowen Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $146.29 -10.1% +7.3% +11.5% +19.7% $175 hit
2025-10-31 UBS Buy → Buy maintained Bullish $146.29 -10.1% +7.3% +11.5% +19.7% $200 close
2025-10-21 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained Leans bullish · Equal-Weight, target +13% $156.79 -7.7% -3.3% +3.0% +9.0% $178 hit
2025-10-13 Raymond James Outperform → Strong Buy upgrade Bullish $158.75 -3.0% +2.8% +4.7% $210 missed
2025-10-08 Barclays Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $159.37 -6.5% -1.5% +4.2% $201 missed
2025-10-01 Morgan Stanley Equal-Weight → Equal-Weight maintained Leans bullish · Equal-Weight, target +15% $162.64 -10.1% -3.5% +0.3% $188 missed
2025-09-25 JPMorgan Overweight → Overweight maintained Bullish $167.28 -4.5% -8.6% -2.8% $203 missed

Also in Brokers & Exchanges

SCHWIBKRHOODCMEBrokers & Exchanges vs IAI →

Interactive version with the price chart and target overlay: Scorecard tab on the dashboard. All covered names: index.

How the grading works

Every sell-side rating change from the last 365 days is priced the day it lands and checked again 30, 60 and 90 days later. A call is a hit when the stock moved in the called direction at 30 days. Buy- and Sell-side ratings call their own direction. A Hold is read, not waved through: a downgrade to Hold is graded as a bearish call and an upgrade to Hold as a bullish one, and a maintained Hold whose price target sits 10%+ above the price leans bullish (10%+ below, leans bearish) and is graded that way. A Hold with a target close to the price is a true Hold and is not graded at all. Every call with a price target also gets a target check 90 days later: hit (reached it or within 5%), close (covered at least half the distance) or missed. A firm's accuracy on a single name prints only after 4 scored calls, and a firm gets its own page only after 10 scored calls across every covered name — below that a percentage is noise. "Run before the call" is the stock's move over the 30 calendar days before the rating landed. Data: Yahoo Finance rating history and daily closes, rebuilt each morning. Nothing on this page is advice.

Get the 7 AM brief

The AM take, today's docket and the Street's calls — one email, weekdays, before the open.